Spotify Wins Lawsuit Over Bundling Strategy That Decreased Payments to Songwriters

Spotify has scored a legal victory that could have lasting consequences for how songwriters get paid in the streaming era.
Spotify successfully fended off a lawsuit from the Mechanical Licensing Collective (MLC), which alleged that the company unlawfully slashed songwriter royalties by reclassifying its Premium subscriptions as "bundles" to include audiobooks. U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres reportedly ruled in favor of the streaming giant after determining its proprietors acted within the law when they adjusted the platform's payout structure.
The dispute began in early-2024, when Spotify began including 15 hours of audiobook access in its Premium plans. By labeling these subscriptions as "bundles," Spotify qualified for a lower mechanical royalty rate under Phonorecords IV, a 2022 settlement between music publishers and streaming services, per Music Business Worldwide.
The MLC, a nonprofit designated to administer digital mechanical royalties, took legal action in May, arguing that Spotify had "unilaterally and unlawfully" reduced payments to songwriters by as much as 50%.
Judge Torres rejected the MLC's claims, stating that Spotify’s interpretation of the law was the only "plausible" one. The decision could set a precedent for other streaming services looking to restructure their content offerings accordingly.
"Under the facts as alleged, audiobook streaming is a product or service that is distinct from music streaming and has more than token value," Torres said. "Premium is, therefore, properly categorized as a bundle, and the allegations of the complaint do not plausibly suggest otherwise."
Spotify welcomed the ruling, characterizing it a validation of its business model. The MLC, meanwhile, expressed deep concerns and indicated that an appeal may be on the table.
MIXTV PUSH
VEZANE VIJESTI DJ
A Canadian Collision: MENEW, Dzeko and BYOR Cross Genre Lines on ‘Never Us’
Dancing Astronaut’s New Music Friday: February 7, 2025
Alan Walker to Headline Open-Air Concert at Central Park In Summer 2025
From Warner’s Spotify and Amazon deals to Sir Lucian Grainge’s 2025 memo… it’s MBW’s Weekly Round-Up
Dancing Astronaut Presents: IDs Only Episode 2 – San Holo [Interview]
Apashe's Philharmonic Orchestra Show Is Unlike Anything You've Ever Seen
J Dilla Street unveiled in Detroit in honour of hip-hop producer's birthday
Zedd, Tiësto and Disclosure Top Colossal Lineup for FVDED In The Park 2025
Burning Man introduces controversial tiered ticket pricing model for 2025
POPULARNO
Esports Insider unveils finalists for The Clutch Digital
Ispunili ste sve dječje želje: hvala vam 170 puta!
Blagdani 2024 na Enteru!
Ovo su najbolje zimske SPF kreme uz koje ćete bezbrižno skijati
Tihe vode dobrog zvuka
Hrvatski producenti na listi najboljih Jackin House izdanja 2024. prema Traxsourceu!
DJ JOCK je Ambasadorov DJ godine!
Esports events calendar 2025: Major leagues and tournaments
Isplati li se u 2025. kupiti dizajnerske tenisice?
Redmi Note 14 5G in for review
Sven Väth se vraća u Zagreb!
Rare Beauty novitet dolazi o obliku njihovih popularnih tekućih rumenila
Karmine Corp CEO claims profitability for second year in a row
Sonos mijenja vodstvo nakon debakla s aplikacijom
Forestland otkrio planove za 2025. godinu!
Objavljen teaser druge sezone “The Last Of Us” uz datum izlaska
‘Ja sam Tim’ – dokumentarac o Aviciiju od danas na Netflixu
Jall Aux Yeux
Ludwig and MoistCr1tiKaL named Shopify Rebellion co-owners
IDEM
U.D.O. + The Madcap
Microsoft osniva novi Core AI odjel
Imamo video snimke s nastupa Pan-Pota u Boogaloo klubu
Parni Valjak obilježava 50 godina djelovanja velikom turnejom “50”
UK organisation Endpoint partners with TikTok to launch new creator network
Ferreck Dawn stiže u Zagreb!
Pilot-projekt testiranja droga: Hoće li festivali postati sigurniji?
Tindersticks
Rock The Opera
JD Gaming launches fan engagement platform with XBorg
Tecno demos Starry Optical Fiber technology at CES
Nvidia announces RTX 50-series graphics cards with DLSS 4
Microlino Spider ide u osvajanje Amerike
Zavodljive usne kakve imaju heroine u romantičnim komedijama su novi TikTok trend
U Hrvatskoj je 2024. prodano 12,54 posto više novih automobila nego li godinu prije
Grok AI chatbot dostupan kao zasebna iOS aplikacija
Instagram announces Edits, its CapCut rival
Mrva promovira solo projekt 08. siječnja u zagrebačkom Vintageu
Tek 13 europskih startupa je lani došlo do statusa 'jednoroga'
Pankrti
Reper Tibor u Vintageu slavi 10 godina albuma Pacino i Tvrdokor labela
Samsung Galaxy S25 Slim not releasing until May
Musk se ne prestaje miješati u europsku politiku i odluke. Čelnici država su bijesni
Xiaomi sljedećeg tjedna na europsko tržište dovodi Redmi Note 14
BLAST Bounty Season 1: Format, Fixtures and More
Britanci oštri prema preprodavačima ilegalnog IPTV-a, jedan dobio dvije godine zatvora
G2 Esports and Oxygen Esports qualify for Six Invitational
Poznato je zašto neka vina uzrokuju glavobolje, a druga ne?
Team Heretics and CGN Esports announce VALORANT partnership
AMD announces new processors for desktops, laptops, and handheld gaming PCs
Redmi Note 14 Pro+ 5G in for review
Super mekane mokasinke nosimo čim to vrijeme dopusti
Barbara Tucker otkriva kako je nastala house himna “Beautiful People”
Joe Satriani: “Kurt Cobain je bio sjajan gitarist”
SAD će savezne agencije početi napajati i nuklearnom energijom kroz dugoročne ugovore
TikTok is live again in the US after 13 hours in the dark
Odabrali ste singl tjedna – Lil Zoo “Oko za oko”
iPhone 17 Air's shocking thinness revealed
Znanstvena istraživanja potvrđuju povezanost alkohola s povećanim rizikom od raka
Ulizivanje Trumpu? Šef UFC-a pridružio se upravnom odboru Mete
